• About
    • About Seattle DogSpot
    • My Dogs
  • Lost Dogs
    • Lost Dog Tips
    • Post Your Lost Dog
  • Adoption & Rescue Tips
  • Advertise
    • Get Featured
    • Free Dog-Friendly Business Decal
  • Contact Us

Seattle DogSpot

Follow Seattle DogSpot on FacebookFollow Seattle DogSpot on InstagramFollow Seattle Dogspot on TwitterFollow Seattle DogSpot on PinterestFollow Seattle DogSpot on YouTube
  • Home
  • Dog News
    • Local News
    • Recalls
  • Dog Friendly Seattle
    • Dog Friendly Businesses
    • Dog Friendly Hotels
  • Where to Play
    • Seattle Area Dog Events
    • Dog Parks
    • Travel With Your Dog
  • Happy Healthy Dog
    • Dog Health & Wellness
    • Dog Training & Behavior
  • Dog Events
    • Master Events Calendar
    • Submit an Event
  • Reviews
You are here: Home / Dog News / Legal Loophole Limits Jail Time for Washington Man Who Sexually Abused Dog

Legal Loophole Limits Jail Time for Washington Man Who Sexually Abused Dog

August 10, 2017 by Seattle DogSpot 2 Comments

Share This!

WARNING – THIS STORY CONTAINS DISTURBING CONTENT

Q13 reported Tuesday that a Thurston County judge sentenced James L. Evans to a year in jail for killing a dog by hanging it from a tree last year.

Rest in Peace Diamond. Photo from Justice (Just “Us”) for Diamond Facebook page..

Judge Carol Murphy sentenced Evans after he pled guilty to first degree animal cruelty.

Diamond was a 3-year-old pit bull mix that was a therapy dog for an 8-year-old boy. Evans had been keeping Diamond for the boy’s relative while she looked for dog friendly housing. He told police he hung the Diamond because she killed his iguana.

A biker found Diamond hanging from a tree on Department of Natural Resources property near Summit Lake. According to court documents Diamond’s toes barely touched the ground, and her front legs were clutching the tree trunk. You could see the scratch marks she left on the bark as she struggled to escape.

A necropsy showed she died from asphyxiation; it also showed evidence of severe trauma to the dog’s anus and rectum.

The Thurston County Prosecutor’s Office originally charged Evans with first-degree animal cruelty but later amended the charge to “first-degree animal cruelty with an aggravating circumstance and/or with sexual motivation.”

This was an important distinction because it would have allowed Judge Murphy to increase Evans’ sentence if he had been convicted.

James L. Evans of Grays Harbor County hung and sexually abused Diamond, a therapy dog for an 8-year-old boy. Image from Q13 Fox.

Unfortunate Language Mitigate Law’s Effectiveness

But he law specifically states that prosecutors would have had to prove Evans sexually abused Diamond “for the purpose of sexual gratification or arousal,”

This provision is ridiculous. Not only is it virtually impossible to prove, study after study has shown that with humans, rape is a crime of power, not passion or sexual arousal, so why should charging someone with sexually abusing an animal be contingent on “sexual gratification or arousal”?

Evans didn’t abuse and Diamond for his sexual pleasure; he did it because she killed his iguana.

“We all wanted a lot more time than that but unfortunately, their hands were tied with the way the RCW Reads right now,” said Thurston County Animal Services Officer Erika Johnson told Q13. “The way the law reads, prosecutors would have had to prove Evans committed the rape for ‘for the purpose of sexual gratification or arousal of the person’. That’s obviously something that’s very hard to prove.” 

Officer Johnson and several members of the Facebook group Justice (Just”Us”) for Diamond
pledged to work with the Legislature to remove the sexual gratification/arousal provision from the current law.

“While we are all frustrated and saddened by the outcome of this, I really would plead with the community to push forward, support us in changing the law, making it a stronger law, to put their anger to good use,” Johnson told Q13.

I plan to honor Diamonds memory by participating in the effort to remove the “sexual gratification/arousal loophole” in the current animal cruelty law. If you’d like to help, join the Justice (Just”Us”) for Diamond Facebook page and watch for announcements.

Share This!

Filed Under: Dog News

Comments

  1. Neghibor says

    August 15, 2017 at 1:54 am

    Could someone from your org contact me about what I do know at this present time about Shepards way and the Anek’s

    Reply
    • Seattle DogSpot says

      August 15, 2017 at 8:16 am

      Just emailed you.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

www.metrodogseattle.com

www.raindogphoto.com

Find info on more events...

Recent Articles

  • Will Grays Harbor County Finally Take Action Against Backyard Breeder?
  • Puyallup Dog Rescue Importing Underage Puppies from Mexico
  • Dogs from Furever Homes Rescue Kill Neighbor’s Goats in Olympia
  • Do NOT Adopt a Belgian Malinois After Watching DOG
  • Main Street Mutt Rescue Dumps Woman After She Asks Questions

[Read more…]

This website or its third-party tools use cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and required to achieve the purposes illustrated in the cookie policy. If you want to know more or withdraw your consent to the use of cookies, please refer to the cookie policy. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to the use of cookies. Cookie Policy

Find it here

Contact:

Seattle DogSpot
info@seattledogspot.com

Return to Top of Page

Copyright © 2023 Seattle DogSpot | Seattle Web Design by Original Ginger

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Refund & Return Policy

 

Loading Comments...